Giftwise vs Giftster: Which Gift App Fits You?

Share this article

Choose Giftwise if you want to plan what you buy, track every gift and stay on budget. Choose Giftster if your family wants to keep private wish lists and reserve gifts without spoiling the surprise.

Giftster is a family wish list app and Giftwise is a planner for the person doing the buying, so they fit together as easily as they compete. Where we could not confirm a detail about Giftster, we say "Check their site" instead of guessing.

Quick comparison

GiftwiseGiftster
Built forThe person buying giftsFamilies sharing wish lists
Budget per personYes, plus a budget per occasionNot its focus
Gift statusIdea, To Buy, Purchased, Wrapped, Given, ReturnedReserved or purchased by a giver; hidden from the list owner on regular accounts
Shared wish listsNoYes, in private groups
Add items from a store linkPaste a store link on a giftYes, with its Fetch feature and a browser extension
Secret SantaFree generator at /secret-santaYes
RemindersEmail before each date, optional pushCheck their site
CostFree for 25 people and 15 gifts per rolling 12 months, Premium $9.99 a yearFree; Giftster may earn affiliate commissions

What Giftwise does well

Giftwise keeps the people you shop for, their occasions and your gift ideas in one place. You set a budget for each occasion and for each person in it, and the app shows money spent next to money you only plan to spend. Every gift moves through Idea, To Buy, Purchased, Wrapped and Given, and there are shopping, wrapping and shipping lists plus reminder emails before each date.

It also stores sizes, interests, return deadlines and receipts, so the details are there when you need them in a store.

What Giftster does well

Giftster is built around private groups, usually a family. Each member keeps a wish list. Reservations and purchases on a regular account are hidden from the list owner but visible to other shoppers, helping prevent duplicate gifts. A parent managing a child account can see the status of items on that child's list. Giftster can add an item from a store link, has a browser extension, supports child accounts and can run a Secret Santa draw.

Where Giftster is better: getting a whole family onto shared wish lists, with reservations hidden from the owner of a regular list. Giftwise keeps your plan private unless you choose to share an occasion with collaborators. Its shared occasions are for planning gifts together, not for recipient wish lists with reservations.

A typical December with each app

With Giftster, everyone in the family adds a few ideas to their list in October, and relatives reserve items as they shop. Reservations on regular accounts stay hidden from the list owner. With Giftwise, you open your Christmas occasion, see that you have $120 left for your sister and two gifts still on the To Buy list, and tap Purchased as you check things off in the store. One app handles what you receive, the other handles what you give.

If you only choose one, ask which problem costs you more: duplicate gifts coming in, or overspending and forgotten gifts going out.

Which should you pick?

  • You want to know what everyone wants: Giftster.
  • You want to know what you have bought, wrapped and spent: Giftwise.
  • You want both: use Giftster for the family lists and Giftwise for your own budget and shopping.

To set a total before you start, try the free holiday budget calculator. For more options, read the best gift tracker apps guide, or the Giftwise and GiftList comparison.

Questions and answers

Is Giftwise better than Giftster?

It depends on the job. Giftwise is better for planning purchases and budgets, and Giftster is better for family wish lists with hidden reservations.

Is Giftster free?

Giftster is free and may earn affiliate commissions on purchases through its links. Giftwise is free for up to 25 people and 15 gifts per rolling 12 months, and Premium is $9.99 a year.

Can I use Giftwise and Giftster together?

Yes. Let your family keep wish lists in Giftster and track your own spending, gift statuses and reminders in Giftwise.

Does Giftwise have wish lists my family can see?

Giftwise keeps your plan private unless you choose to share an occasion with collaborators. It does not offer a recipient wish list where family members can reserve gifts.