Giftwise vs GiftList: Which Gift App Fits You?

Share this article

Choose Giftwise if you are the one doing the buying and want a budget, a status for every gift and reminders. Choose GiftList if you want one shareable wish list that friends and family can shop from without making an account.

The two apps solve different problems, so this is less a contest than a way to decide which one you need, or whether to use both. Everything below about GiftList comes from its public website. Where we could not confirm something, we say "Check their site."

Quick comparison

GiftwiseGiftList
Built forThe person buying giftsThe person making a wish list
Budget per personYes, plus a budget per occasionNot its focus
Gift statusIdea, To Buy, Purchased, Wrapped, Given, ReturnedGivers mark a gift as purchased so others can see it is taken
Shareable wish listNoYes, one link, givers need no account
Add items from any storePaste a store link on a giftPaste a link; GiftList tries to fill in details, or add them manually
RemindersEmail before each date, optional pushBirthday reminders
Secret SantaFree generator at /secret-santaDraw for up to 100 people
AppsWorks in any browser, installable to your home screeniOS and Android apps and a browser extension
CostFree for 25 people and 15 gifts per rolling 12 months, Premium $9.99 a yearFree; external payment services may charge fees

What Giftwise does well

Giftwise is a planner. You add the people you shop for, group gifts by occasion such as Christmas or a birthday, and set a budget for the occasion and for each person. Money you have already spent is shown separately from money you plan to spend, so you can see the effect of a gift before you buy it. Each gift moves from Idea to To Buy, Purchased, Wrapped and Given, and there are shopping, wrapping and shipping lists for the busy weeks.

It also keeps the small details that make gifts better: sizes, interests, past gifts, return deadlines and receipts.

What GiftList does well

GiftList is a wish list and registry. You paste a link from an online store, and GiftList tries to fill in the details. You can add or correct them manually if needed, then share one link with friends and family. Givers buy the item from the store and mark it as purchased so other shoppers can see it is taken. They do not need an account to do that on the website, though the guest form asks for a name and email. Reservations stay hidden from the list owner until they choose to reveal them. GiftList also has family groups, cards, event invitations and a Secret Santa draw for up to 100 people.

Where GiftList is better: if the hard part of your holiday is getting people to tell you what they want, or getting your own relatives to avoid buying you the same thing, GiftList offers recipient wish lists with reservations. Giftwise keeps your plan private unless you choose to share an occasion with collaborators; it does not offer that kind of public wish list.

A typical December with each app

With GiftList, you build your own list in October and send the link to your family. Other shoppers can see which items have been marked as taken, while the status stays hidden from you until you choose to reveal gifts. With Giftwise, you open your Christmas occasion, see that you have $120 left for your sister and two gifts still on the To Buy list, and tap Purchased as you check things off in the store. One app handles what you receive, the other handles what you give.

If you only choose one, ask which problem costs you more: duplicate gifts coming in, or overspending and forgotten gifts going out.

Which should you pick?

  • You buy for many people and want to stay on budget: Giftwise.
  • You want a list others can shop from: GiftList.
  • You want both: let family keep wish lists in GiftList and track your own spending and shopping in Giftwise.

If you are not sure how much to spend yet, split your total across everyone with the free holiday budget calculator. For a wider look at the options, read our guide to the best gift tracker apps, or see the Giftwise and Giftster comparison.

Questions and answers

Is Giftwise better than GiftList?

It depends on the job. Giftwise is better for planning what you buy and spend, and GiftList is better for sharing a wish list that others can shop from.

Is GiftList free?

GiftList says it is free to use; external payment services for cash funds or group gifts may charge fees. Giftwise is free for up to 25 people and 15 gifts per rolling 12 months, and Premium is $9.99 a year.

Can I use Giftwise and GiftList together?

Yes. You can share a wish list from GiftList and keep your own budget, gift statuses and reminders in Giftwise.

Does Giftwise have a shareable wish list?

Giftwise keeps your plan private unless you choose to share an occasion with collaborators. It does not offer a public recipient wish list for family to add to or reserve from.