The Gift-Giving Hall of Shame

Share this article

We've all had a gift-giving idea that sounded better in our heads.

Maybe you grabbed something at the last minute and immediately wondered whether it was quite right. Maybe you forgot the occasion altogether. Or maybe you gave someone a bowling ball with your own name engraved on it.

That last one is mostly a Homer Simpson problem.

Welcome to the Giftwise Gift-Giving Hall of Shame, where fictional gift mishaps give us permission to laugh and a few ideas for doing better. We're celebrating the comedy of the situations, not judging anyone for spending less, making a gift by hand or forgetting something during a busy season.

Spoilers ahead for The Simpsons, Friends and The Office.

1. Homer Simpson's bowling ball: The gift that's really for you

In the Simpsons episode “Life on the Fast Lane,” Homer gives Marge a bowling ball for her birthday. There are two clues that he may not have put her interests first: it has his name engraved on it, and its finger holes fit his hand.

Marge decides to keep the ball and learn to bowl herself. The gesture still sends a pretty clear message about who Homer expected to use it.

The mistake: Choosing what you want and assuming the other person wants it too.

Try this instead: Start with the recipient's preferences. A board game, cooking gadget or experience can be a great shared gift when both people actually want it. If you're unsure, ask a question before you buy: “Would you enjoy doing this together?” is a lot more useful than engraving your own name on it.

Giftwise idea: Save a note about something they mentioned liking. When it's time to shop, check the note before falling in love with an idea meant for you.

2. Phoebe's gifts for Joey: The present with an ulterior motive

In the Friends episode “The One With the Holiday Armadillo,” Phoebe gives Joey a drum set and a tarantula. Monica suggests the gifts were meant to drive Rachel out of Joey's apartment, and when asked, Phoebe admits that on some level that may be true.

The mistake: Using a gift to get someone else to do what you want.

Try this instead: Give people room to make their own choices. If you miss a friend or want to spend more time together, tell them directly. An invitation to coffee is a much clearer message than a pet spider with a secret agenda.

And when a gift involves a living animal, a large item or a recurring cost, ask first. The recipient's home, household and preferences matter more than the surprise.

3. Monica and Chandler's Valentine's gifts: The last-minute cover-up

In another Friends episode, “The One With Unagi,” Monica and Chandler plan to celebrate Valentine's Day by making gifts for each other. Chandler can't come up with anything to make, and Monica forgets until the last minute. She gives Chandler a sock puppet that Phoebe made, while Chandler gives Monica a tape of music that he had actually received from Janice.

It's difficult to recover smoothly from a gift with that kind of backstory.

The mistake: Pretending a rushed gift is something it isn't.

Try this instead: Be honest if you've forgotten or run out of time. A simple “I meant to make something and I didn't get it done. Can I take you out for coffee this weekend?” is kinder than inventing an elaborate backstory.

Regifting itself isn't the problem. Passing along something useful or meaningful can be thoughtful when it suits the recipient and you're honest about it. The sock puppet isn't on trial here, and neither are handmade gifts.

Giftwise idea: Add an important occasion and save a potential idea when you think of one. If the date sneaks up anyway, you still have a starting point.

4. Michael Scott's office exchange: The rules change after everyone shops

At the office Christmas party in The Office, the Secret Santa spending limit is $20. Michael buys Ryan a $400 iPod. After receiving a knitted oven mitt from Phyllis, he reacts poorly and turns the exchange into a Yankee Swap.

Suddenly, Jim's carefully chosen gift for Pam is at risk of going home with someone else, and the iPod becomes the prize everyone wants.

The mistake: Ignoring the group's budget and changing the format after people have prepared.

Try this instead: Agree on the spending limit and format before anyone shops. Let people know whether they're choosing for one person or bringing a general gift to a group swap. If the group wants different rules, decide together in advance.

When someone gives you something that isn't your taste, thank them for the thought. Phyllis's handmade gift deserves appreciation, even if Michael had imagined something else.

The real lesson: Keep the person in the picture

A funny fictional gift fail is easy to spot from the couch. Real-life gifting is messier. People have different budgets, full calendars and imperfect memories. A missed occasion or an awkward choice doesn't make you a bad friend.

A little attention can help: listen for what someone enjoys, respect any agreed budget and keep notes when an idea comes to you. If you get it wrong, a sincere apology and a conversation go a long way.

And if a bowling ball does seem perfect, perhaps check whose name is on it first.

Want a little help remembering what your people actually like? Add someone to Giftwise and save one detail or gift idea for later.